@LouisIngenthron i think that’s a real concern, but not necessary fatal. every rule we define demands lines be drawn, and there is always risk that advocates will push the lines where initial framers don’t mean them to go. that process, drawing, defending, and deciding after all to let shift lines is much of what our court system struggles with everyday. i’m not sure this set of proscriptions of official (and only official) speech would be slipperier than lots of other lines we draw. /fin