@Phil@freeatlantis.com @adamgurri I hope the subsequent 37 have been longer and so, so much better. (Although not, like, paradisiacal. We’d not have the benefit of your orneriness if it was all roses and angel’s wings.)
@dodgytheories @phillmv @adamgurri the road to hell is thick with roads not taken.
@dodgytheories @phillmv @adamgurri yup. a revolt against the establishment. about half took it towards Sanders-ish politics, the other half took it straight to MAGA.
@Phil@freeatlantis.com @adamgurri I have been to those places. Yes, things are expensive because of the steep VAT, but ordinary pay is much better too, everything is better, and a big garage full of crap is not my idea of a good life.
They are overall much more successful countries than we are. It’s only hard to become affluent if you define affluent by distinction, in relative terms. Nearly everyone there enjoys the kind of security that only unusual affluence can purchase in the US.
@admitsWrongIfProven@qoto.org people have tried some open-source hardware, some-variant-of-linux-running phones, right? (obviously i haven’t.)
one perhaps saving grace is that smartphones are so prominent and essential that regulatory and antitrust authorities take note and sometimes act, especially in Europe (less corrupted by Apple and Google and claims of being a home-team champion).
however begrudgingly, one has to hand the administration some credit for finally securing the northern border. no one crosses it into the United States anymore.
@admitsWrongIfProven@qoto.org yeah, i agree, ultimately architecture is destiny and profit-motivated, centralized, near-monopoly platforms are destined to enshittify.
i don't know that any service has enjoyed an enshittification arc quite as steep as meetup.com, which briefly seemed like a revolutionary and essential utility and now seems like a scammy, spammy backwater.
i'm sorry for it too, because in its heyday i think it genuinely did lubricate and encourage in-person civil society. nothing as convenient and effective has emerged to supersede it.
@Phil@freeatlantis.com @adamgurri i really like what’s been tried in Norway and Finland and Denmark, and to lesser degrees elsewhere. nothing lasts forever without continual supervision and renewal, but the virtues of those systems have outlasted the virtues of ours (of which i was quite fond in my younger days, i once had views not so different from yours, but as you say, it is good to actually observe the consequences of what has been tried).
@Phil@freeatlantis.com @adamgurri Better corrupt and evil government than evil private power that is only not corrupt because it can be openly predatory without having to pretend to serve a public interest.
I don’t think well of your opinions (though it’s fun to chat!) either, but I’ll try to refrain from the insults.
@Phil@freeatlantis.com @adamgurri As I say, we agree its disagreeable when in our name and with our resources government does what we abhor. But I think it most disagreeable to allow private power to concentrate and act without fetters. Government is like fire, a technology that if incautiously applied will burn your house down, but you tame it, don’t abjure it, because you require it to keep you warm. Or, in the case of government, to keep you free from the depredations of concentrated private power.
@Phil@freeatlantis.com @adamgurri I agree that the way out is dispersal of power. But since I view money as the primary source and marker of power in a society like ours, dispersing power means reducing and preventing wealth concentration, and government, for all its difficulties and pathologies, is the only institution capable of achieving that.
@admitsWrongIfProven@qoto.org don’t worry, the simulation is only simulated, we needn’t take it so seriously.
@Phil@freeatlantis.com @adamgurri money is power, nothing more or less. it doesn’t “buy things”, it only influences human behavior. influencing human behavior is the very role and purpose of money. none of us should be shocked that it influences the behavior of legislators through a variety of channels. if you have institutional suggestions about how to insulate them from influence, we’re all ears. if your solution is less government, well that leaves only money as power, even worse.
@GuerillaOntologist i agree that the current system selects pathologically. i disagree that sortition under anything like existing institutions would be much better. selection effects would be replaced by capture effects, the selected would very quickly cease to be representative by virtue of their selection and ensuing experience, and not just in desirable ways like learning to act in their new roles on behalf of the public.